Escape Artists
Escape Pod => About Escape Pod => Topic started by: Clear Air Turbulence on September 22, 2009, 01:40:42 AM
-
Well, I don't want the sort who registers just to criticize, but..
I enjoy Escape Pod; I hadn't listened to it for several months but just came back. I've noticed the last few episodes that the voice at the beginning says "Episode two hundred AND sixteen".
What's that AND doing there? I'm certain Sister Mary Mara told me that was incorrect. Am I being too pedantic?
(Fun story, anyway.)
-
Am I being too pedantic?
TOO PEDANTIC? For an Internet forum? Surely, young...person whose gender is indeterminate, you've learned by now that there is no such thing. :)
-
Well, I don't want the sort who registers just to criticize, but..
I enjoy Escape Pod; I hadn't listened to it for several months but just came back. I've noticed the last few episodes that the voice at the beginning says "Episode two hundred AND sixteen".
What's that AND doing there? I'm certain Sister Mary Mara told me that was incorrect. Am I being too pedantic?
(Fun story, anyway.)
I also think it might be different depending on Country. I think we drop the and in America, but not sure on the Brits. The Chinese English teachers put the and in. So does the computer courseware at the English learning center I work at. It annoys me. I told the students that in America we were taught not to put and in there. They of course want to put it all over it. I told them if they use and they can only put it for the tens and nowhere else. otherwise you wind up with one million and 5 hundred and 45 thousand, 3 hundred and 32 for example.
-
Well, I don't want the sort who registers just to criticize, but..
I enjoy Escape Pod; I hadn't listened to it for several months but just came back. I've noticed the last few episodes that the voice at the beginning says "Episode two hundred AND sixteen".
What's that AND doing there? I'm certain Sister Mary Mara told me that was incorrect. Am I being too pedantic?
(Fun story, anyway.)
I also think it might be different depending on Country. I think we drop the and in America, but not sure on the Brits. The Chinese English teachers put the and in. So does the computer courseware at the English learning center I work at. It annoys me. I told the students that in America we were taught not to put and in there. They of course want to put it all over it. I told them if they use and they can only put it for the tens and nowhere else. otherwise you wind up with one million and 5 hundred and 45 thousand, 3 hundred and 32 for example.
Using the arbiter of all things, Google, "One hundred and sixteen" begets 2,350,000 results, and "One hundred sixteen" begets a paltry 37,300 results.
However, the most critical fact is that there are One Hundred And One Dalmatians .
-
interesting. i'm not sure what it means, but when you compare "two hundred sixteen"/"two hundred and sixteen" they pretty much even out at 4.5mil each. for "three hundred sixteen"/"three hundred and sixteen" the and loses by 4.6mil:2.2mil. it only get worse from there. so, colloquially, and seems to be acceptable for one and maybe two hundred.
but a vixen like virtual vikki gets away with things the rest of us could only dream of. man. flying in the face of recognized english grammar, girl knows how to party.
-
Well, I don't want the sort who registers just to criticize, but..
I enjoy Escape Pod; I hadn't listened to it for several months but just came back. I've noticed the last few episodes that the voice at the beginning says "Episode two hundred AND sixteen".
What's that AND doing there? I'm certain Sister Mary Mara told me that was incorrect. Am I being too pedantic?
(Fun story, anyway.)
I also think it might be different depending on Country. I think we drop the and in America, but not sure on the Brits. The Chinese English teachers put the and in. So does the computer courseware at the English learning center I work at. It annoys me. I told the students that in America we were taught not to put and in there. They of course want to put it all over it. I told them if they use and they can only put it for the tens and nowhere else. otherwise you wind up with one million and 5 hundred and 45 thousand, 3 hundred and 32 for example.
Using the arbiter of all things, Google, "One hundred and sixteen" begets 2,350,000 results, and "One hundred sixteen" begets a paltry 37,300 results.
However, the most critical fact is that there are One Hundred And One Dalmatians .
Um, you're going to use Disney to settle this? How about a real SF source, like Arthur C. Clarke?
-
My mother goes nuts over this. See took accounting in school way back when and it was part of her work on and off for forty-five years. "And" is only used for "and 25 cents". Anything else is wrong. Now the real question is if we let it slip or not. There are tons of "mistakes" we let slip everyday.
This one, I think, is a losing battle. I teach my kids the "right" way, but I hear all of the other parents and the teacher using the "wrong" way. This is the type of thing that needs to be taught from the beginning. Trying to change it later rarely works.
-
To me, it's what sounds right. Star Trek's "To boldly go..." is a split infinitive, but "To go boldly...." just doesn't have the right cadence, so what's wrong actually sounds better. In the case of the "and" in the episode numbers, I felt it was put there specifically because of the text-to-speech program used to speak those words aloud. It just doesn't sound right without it, in her voice.
At least that's my opinion.
-
To me, it's what sounds right. Star Trek's "To boldly go..." is a split infinitive, but "To go boldly...." just doesn't have the right cadence, so what's wrong actually sounds better.
That's because it's not wrong. There is no reason to avoid so-called "split infinitives" in English. The "rule" comes from a couple of cranky old guys in the seventeenth century who thought Latin was the ideal language, and since Latin infinitives are one word and therefore you can't jam an adverb in there, you shouldn't do it in English either. Totally goofy, and nothing whatever to do with actual English. Same for ending sentences with prepositions--feel free to do so. Oh, and singular they, too. Absolutely grammatically fine. Whether or not it turns up on a grade school English teacher's list of things he'll mark your paper red for is irrelevant. Really.
As for numbers, when such questions come up, I usually consult Language Log (http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=1434).
-
To me, it's what sounds right. Star Trek's "To boldly go..." is a split infinitive, but "To go boldly...." just doesn't have the right cadence, so what's wrong actually sounds better.
That's because it's not wrong. There is no reason to avoid so-called "split infinitives" in English. The "rule" comes from a couple of cranky old guys in the seventeenth century who thought Latin was the ideal language, and since Latin infinitives are one word and therefore you can't jam an adverb in there, you shouldn't do it in English either. Totally goofy, and nothing whatever to do with actual English. Same for ending sentences with prepositions--feel free to do so. Oh, and singular they, too. Absolutely grammatically fine. Whether or not it turns up on a grade school English teacher's list of things he'll mark your paper red for is irrelevant. Really.
As for numbers, when such questions come up, I usually consult Language Log (http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=1434).
If I hadn't caught a second circuit court decision story halfway through my post that would have been the next place I would have looked. Language log is a great blog.
-
You know what really prompted this? Well, every time I hear it, it rankles, but then I think: "Does their text-to-speech application actually throw the 'and' in there automatically, or does someone have to go in and edit the text?"
And I assume the latter, that it's inserted on purpose by someone, and that just rankles more!
Yes, I fully understand this is MY PROBLEM. Yes, I have Fowler's AND the Dictionary of Modern American Usage at home. At least a podcast can't confuse "its" and "it's".
-
You should check out this thread (http://forum.escapeartists.net/index.php?topic=716.0) and chime in!
-
You know what really prompted this? Well, every time I hear it, it rankles, but then I think: "Does their text-to-speech application actually throw the 'and' in there automatically, or does someone have to go in and edit the text?"
EP uses the text-to-speech that is built into OSX. I just did a test. I typed in "216". Vicki (that's the name of the voice) "said", "two-hundred and sixteen". So there's your answer.
BTW, I#m with you on this one and don't get me started on the over-use of reflexive pronouns.
-
I think this might be a country thing. Here in the UK, the 'and' is used, although generally only between the hundreds and tens, so 116 == 'one hundred and sixteen', while 1116 == 'one thousand, one hundred and sixteen'.
-
We appear to be approaching the english language as if someone sat down in the beginning and figured things out in a logical manner.
-
*door is kicked down and thread is floded whith tear gas*
i clame this thread in the name of the peopels army for gramatical revoluton!!!
-
We appear to be approaching the english language as if someone sat down in the beginning and figured things out in a logical manner.
Yeah, for realz. You want a language that was worked out deliberately? Speak Esperanto.
-
The 'and' is put in for anything under 100 (at least here in Brit-land, anyways).
So you'd get 1,000,004 being "1 million and 4", or 1005204 being "1 million, 5 thousand, 2 hundred and 4"
I can't say that I've ever gone deliberately looking, but I've never noticed people reading out numbers (in English) in any other way.
[edit: the 'and' is put in for any whole number or fraction below 100 (so anything beyond the decimal point is 'and' less. Unless there is another number below 100. This is getting too complicated. ]
-
EP uses the text-to-speech that is built into OSX. I just did a test. I typed in "216". Vicki (that's the name of the voice) "said", "two-hundred and sixteen". So there's your answer.
Yeah, voice Vicki has been around since at least System 7 in the late '80s or early '90s or whenever.
I had voice Alex say "EP216: βoyfriend", and it came out "eee pee two one six, boyfriend"
I also tried "216" a couple of times while changing some of the Regional settings in the System Preferences control panel, thinking it might make a difference, but all of them came out "two hundred and sixteen".
I'm still waiting for Vicki to get a voice acting part in one of the stories, and not just the episode opening.
-
*door is kicked down and thread is floded whith tear gas*
i clame this thread in the name of the peopels army for gramatical revoluton!!!
Suddenly reminded of Downfall of Grammar (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8fbrUjjivw), on Youtube.
I don't know if the audio is NSFW. It may depend on where you are.