Miniature 20: Okra, Sorghum, Yam

[Heradel]

Miniature 20: Okra, Sorghum, Yam

By Bruce Holland Rogers
Read by An Owomoyela

In his vegetable garden, Old Kwaku planted collard and okra and cowpeas. He showed the second princess how to cut the weeds down with a sharpened stick.

“I don’t think I’m learning any wisdom,” she said. “And look at my hands! Imagine what they’ll look like at the end of the summer!”

“Here is part of wisdom,” Old Kwaku said, and he began to rearrange some okra pods while they were still on their mother plants. He pulled one and nudged another and coaxed a third. He moved this one and that one together and tied the pods together in the shape of a little green person.

“That doesn’t look like wisdom to me,” the princess said. “Oh, I’m going to go home and die in my father’s house, an old maid!”

Rated G. Contains three princesses.

[stePH]

ummm ... what? 

[internalogic]

Okay.  I get it and it's a fine idea and well-told in many regards.

Our lives are brief and we waste them in empty passions and obsessions.  The wisest course is to appreciate existence for the miraculous gift that it is, to see how we are like plants grown within the bounty of nature, feeding on that bounty, and ultimately feeding it with our bodies and beings.  It's well-done and I get it.  Keep this picture in mind, and like old Kwaku, you can live a life that's worthy of the gift.  This is the teaching of the Buddha as well.

But, the last sentence irks me.  I admire the author's subversiveness for ending the story like that.  But it still irks me.

[eytanz]

Once again, I must admire PC's choice of flash fiction. This was wonderful on every level. And the last sentence was great - it was a perfect coda, entirely consistent, explaining everything, and yet, to me, entirely unexpected.

[Zathras]

I'd thought this was familiar.  Is there a story about the 3rd princess gaining wisdom?

[hatton]

And while it isn't needed - it was somewhat jarring to jump into what felt like the middle of the story.  The lead-in says, "
Rated G. Contains three princesses."  Sorry, there was mention of two of them, the story was about one.

Did we miss something?

[eytanz]

There was mention of three princesses, though only one appeared as a character.

[Rachel Swirsky]

The first princess had already failed, the second princess was the main character, the third princess was yet to try.

[Zathras]

The first princess had already failed, the second princess was the main character, the third princess was yet to try.

Somewhere in folk lore or mythology is there a story about the 3rd princess?

[Rachel Swirsky]

Of this story specifically? As far as I know, Bruce Holland Rogers made it up.

However, a great many folk tales involve three siblings (often, but not always women) who have to engage with a test of character, such as whether they will be kind to an old woman on the road (who turns out to be a fairy). The elder two fail. The youngest (the third, usually) succeeds.

These stories usually focus on the third princess. This story focuses on one of the ones who fails.

[Zathras]

Thank you, Rachel

[Ragtime]

Did this story take place in the winter, very close to the Arctic Circle?  Each "day" appeared to be only two or three minutes long.

Also, the princess was too "scared" to eat the first day, too "greedy" to eat the second, and too "?" to eat the third?

The first day I got, but after that, I wasn't really believing that whatever was going on with the sorghum and sweet potatoes would really keep a hungry girl from eating.

[Talia]

Of this story specifically? As far as I know, Bruce Holland Rogers made it up.

However, a great many folk tales involve three siblings (often, but not always women) who have to engage with a test of character, such as whether they will be kind to an old woman on the road (who turns out to be a fairy). The elder two fail. The youngest (the third, usually) succeeds.

These stories usually focus on the third princess. This story focuses on one of the ones who fails.

Well that clears things up. I like the story about 200% more now that I "get it."

I enjoy this style of story and I thought this was well done, even if the .. "point" of it if you will went over my head until it was pointed out.

[Hyperion]

I can’t believe people would miss the point of this story, but then again, after Disney’s criminal bastardization of Fairy Tales, maybe it’s not so mysterious.

The point of a Fairy Tale is not for the protaganist to succeed, or in this case, “gain wisdom,” the point is for the listener to gain wisdom. As such, Fairy Tales can be stories of overcoming obstacles, or they can be cautionary tales.

Or, to use Editor Swirky’s archetype, WE are the third sister.

The actual wisdom that we (and for that matter, the princess) can glean from the situation is immense. It is also both philosophical and practical.

Our lives are short, and to live them in fear, in constant desire of something better, and with constant anger over our present is to miss what’s going on.

And if THAT’S not enough, we could miss a meal!

And if THAT’S not enough, at the very least we should learn that you’re never going to get the long end of the stick from a man who can make Dancing Yams.

Words to live by.

What these “adults” have missed kids would grasp intuitively.

Bloody well done, Mr. Bruce Holland Rogers. Olk Kwaku would be proud.

[Dwango]

This went outside the box.  I like that in a fable.  The princess failing to recognize the lessons actually made them more poignant for me.  It reminds me that not everyone automatically gets it.  We each learn our own lessons from what we read or hear.  That also means if some of the readers did not "get it", it was their own interpretation of the story they did not get.  Its more interesting to see why we fail than why we succeed as we really only learn from our failures.  The princess allowed the various failings in the dolls to become her own failings, without recognizing they were her own failings.  And the last statement was delectable, as we must imagine our own view of successfully learning the lessons.  Really nice story.

[Anarkey]

PC, you are putting a smile on my face. 

Observe: 

Very nice.  And kudos to Bruce Holland Rogers.  The Keyhole Opera is on my list, from when VanderMeer recommended it on his blog a while back, but sadly, I haven't gotten to it yet (my list is looooooooong, some might qualify it as interminable) so it's nice to have a little taste in the interim between finding out about an author and getting around to read his stuff.  And maybe he gets a nudge upward from my exposure to him here. 

[Loz]

Well, having to have the point of the story explained makes this story a failure for me. However, I really enjoyed the reader and hope we can hear them do more stories in future.

[stePH]

Well, having to have the point of the story explained makes this story a failure for me. However, I really enjoyed the reader and hope we can hear them do more stories in future.

I imagine that those who "got" the story would say the failure lies with those of us who didn't.

[Loz]

Well, having to have the point of the story explained makes this story a failure for me.

I imagine that those who "got" the story would say the failure lies with those of us who didn't.

Which is why I said it didn't work 'for me'. I don't care what The Brights say.

[Listener]

I "got" the story, but I didn't really like it. I don't think the princess as a character was at all sympathetic, and the vegetable men weren't either. Old Kwaku was also static. We had to wait too long for the payoff at the end, and as a fable this was too long to really work for me as a story.

The reading was passable.