Heh. Well. Yes. Probably. I'm trying to remember what story the feedback was for that episode...but drawing a blank. (It was on the Curandero and the Swede episode.)
But since people seem curious - yeah, generally when I do feedback I try to pick things people have said that are interesting, intelligent, or funny. Mostly, things that make me smile or think. I'm not always balanced - I tend to run more positive comments than critical comments (although, since I think we're generally awesome, I'd say it's a fair representation, yo!) That said, I do try and give people room to say they didn't like a story (and why) if they didn't, especially if an episode seemed to not go over well. One thing I usually don't pick up is when listeners try and tell the author how they wanted the story to be written or what would've made it more awesome.
But yeah - personally, I love doing the feedback segments. I think it help builds community and gets people excited to discuss the stories, and I love reading the discussions. When EP stopped doing feedback, I was sad, and I'm happy it's back now.