Okay, I've listened to it now. This episode was coincidentally the first Podcastle episode that was pumped through my car speakers.
I think I've already commented on these during the contest, so I'll be brief:
The Water Sprite was good, not in my personal top three of the contest, but well written with an interesting idea.
Bibliophages--I'm very glad this one made it to the final. Yes it doesn't really have an arc, and is mostly an explanation of the premise, but it's such a COOL premise, and I think this sort of story is perfect for a bite-size flash style.
Fetch--This is still my favorite from the whole contest, and the story transferred well to audio. It's quite a feat to get me to like a cat story--usually I just groan and say "Oh God, another fantasy cat story?" But I really liked this cat, and I liked how his gifts escalated from the commonplace to the unusual to the impractical to the impossible, especially the basement full of cash. The escalation from the commonplace to the absurd made it funny and fun. Loved it!
Also, it was fun to hear the feedback for each story, and I liked hearing eytanz's voice, for I think the first time.