Oh, man...
I'm not doing this to be obnoxious, but I looked at the boards and thought 'oh yeah I need to listen to that'. Then I glanced at the comments and realized I had listened to it. Somehow, the quality that made it haunting to others made it elusive for me.
I am usually a fan of the understated, but something about this felt just a little too understated. The goals of this group were so nebulous at first, and took up such a significant part of the bandwidth of the story that the eerie wendigo/skinwalker presence in the second part of the story, for me, was eclipsed. If the temporal lens of the story had stayed just a bit longer in the desert, or had excised the entire first bar scene, I think that the entire thing would have been dynamite. As it is, the amount of time spent defining his female friend (her name, unsurprisingly, escapes me) and her fierce character was kind of wasted, given how little of her there was in the main portion of the story.