Well, personally I think that "The hand your dealt" deserves to outlive quite a lot of the stories on this list, but I don't think it should win, and I feel it's benefitting inordinantly from your campaign against "Set this down". Hence, I'm shaving off some of its points.
For the record, I'm really tempted to help kill "Set this down" just because I'm tired of the back-and-forth about it, but I didn't listen to it and I therefore don't want to vote (+ or -) for it.