EP417: Southpaw

[eytanz]

EP417: Southpaw

by Bruce McAllister

Read by bdoomed

--

Fidel stands on the pitcher’s mound, dazed. For an instant he doesn’t know where he is. It is a pitcher’s mound. It is a baseball diamond, and there is a woman—the woman he loves—out there in the stands with her beautiful blonde hair and her very American name waving to him, because she loves him, too. It is July. He is sure of this. It is ’51 or ’52. He cannot remember which. But the crowd is as big as ever and he can smell the leather of his glove, and he knows he is playing baseball—the way, as a child in the sugarcane fields of Oriente Province, he always dreamed he might.

His fastball is a problem, but he throws one anyway, it breaks wide and the ump calls the ball. He throws a curve this time, a fine one, and it’s a strike—the third. He grins at Westrum, his catcher, his friend. The next batter’s up. Fidel feels an itching on his face and reaches up to scratch it. It feels like the beginning of a beard, but that can’t be. You keep a clean face in baseball. He tried to tell his father that, in Oriente, the last time he went home, but the old man, as always, had just argued.
He delivers another curve—with great control—and smiles when the ball drops off the table and Sterling swings like an idiot. He muscles up on the pitch, blows the batter down with a heater, but Williams gets a double off the next slider, Miller clears the bases with a triple, and they bring Wilhelm in to relieve him at last. The final score is 9 to 4, just like the oddsmakers predicted, and that great centerfielder Mays still won’t look at him in the lockers.

Nancy—her name is Nancy—is waiting for him at the back entrance when he’s in his street clothes again, the flowered shirt and the white ducks he likes best, and she looks wonderful. She’s chewing gum, which drives him crazy, but her skin is like a dream—like moonlight on the Mulano—and he kisses her hard, feeling her tongue between his lips. When they pull away she says: “I really like the way you walked that Negro in the fifth.”
He smiles at her. He loves her so much it hurts. She doesn’t know a damn thing about the game and nothing about Cuba, but she’s doing her best and she loves him, too. “I do it for you, chica,” he tells her. “I always do it for you.”
That night he dreams he’s in the mountains of the Sierra Maestra, at a place called La Playa. He has no idea why he’s here. He’s never dreamt this dream before. He’s lying on the ground with a rifle in his hand. He’s wearing the fatigues a soldier wears, and doesn’t understand why—who the two men lying beside him are, what it means. The clothes he’s wearing are rough. His face itches like hell.
When he wakes, she is beside him. The sheet has fallen away from her back, which is to him, and her ass—which is so beautiful, which any man would find beautiful—is there for him and him alone to see. How can anything be more real than this? How can I be dreaming of such things? He can hear a song fading but does not know it. There is a bay—a bay with Naval ships—and the song is fading away.
Guantanamera . . . the voice was singing.
Yo soy un hombre sincero, it sang.
I am a truthful man.
Why, Fidel wonders, was it singing this?

Listen to this week’s Escape Pod!

[flintknapper]

My biggest beef with this one is that Norm said it was an alternative reality in the opening comments. I figured out it was Fidel Castro the first time I heard the guy's name was Fidel. So it wasn't a puzzle at all. I knew where it was going. I am not sure I like puzzles but in this case, the author was not explicitly saying it until the end... so I guess I thought it was meant to be.

The story was not a bad. However, I would have liked the story to read more as a period piece. I think what the story is missing is some additional subtle details of setting. Even the dialogue read as if people were talking today, I think it could have come off a bit more 50s. Maybe, it could have been something as simple as Ritchie Valens playing on the radio or something?

 

[Just Jeff]

So...what was the point? Instead of a rebel leader, Castro becomes a pro baseball player, has some concerns about what's happening back home and makes an inquiry, but carries on. Seems a very bland answer to "what if?"

[Windup]

I'm generally a big fan of alternative history, but what I like is seeing the big-picture alternate outcomes -- the Islamic Europe that arises if Charles Martel picks the wrong infantry formation at the Battle of Tours, for example. 

This was the opposite -- Fidel Castro takes a major league contract, gets a hot girlfriend and a nice TV.   I'm happy for Fidel, I guess, but I'd like to know what's going on in the rest of that world. Does somebody else lead the revolution?  Does the revolution fail? Are the Cuban people and the world in general better or worse off as a result? I kept thinking we would find out, and it never happened. 

So, while it was well-written and Bdoomed was spot-on with the narration, I was left disappointed by the story.


On a side note, if you're going to give warnings -- and I think giving warnings is a good idea -- I think it's good to be comprehensive with them.  If I were the parent of a young child, I probably wouldn't worry much about a single minor curse word, but I really wouldn't want to explain what "taken from behind" meant while driving to school.  Just say'n.... 

[Bdoomed]

I highly suggest reading the notes about the story, published on the escape pod site, after the main story text, for some context that may (or may not) change the lens with which you hear/think about this story.

As for big picture, there was no big picture, not for this Fidel.  He gravitated towards it and was repelled by the political climate of 1950s America.  I think the absence of big picture ends up saying more.  What would a baseball player know about revolution?  What does any one of us know about it?  We are over fed on media and malnourished on fact, imprisoned by our own politics, and Giants player Fidel reflects it.  It's the world where he chooses red hair over his people, continued status quo over something perhaps meaningful and dire.  He places his agency in a television star, because as an enculturated Fidel, he knows nothing else.

I admit I was rather unimpressed and unenthused after first reading the story, but it has grown on me, especially afterconsidering what the author has to say and what the story really has to say.

[MCWagner]

I actually remember reading this one way back when it first turned up in Asimov's.  That I remember it so distinctly from 1993 is a pretty strong mark in it's favor, though my puzzlement over it seems the strongest remembrance.

[DoWhileNot]

I really enjoyed the story and liked the idea of Fidel Castro going to visit Ricky Ricardo.  It was also cool to hear Bdoomed reading this - I thought your reading was great once you got warmed up, but the first couple sentences could have used a little more annunciation.

It was pretty cool to hear another baseball story and had me looking around for my old copy of The Iowa Baseball Confederacy.

[BionicValkyrie]

Liked the reading a lot; the story, kinda meh, except I kept thinking of my brother's neighbor Art Pennington who played in the Negro leagues ... and hit a home run off Fidel (guess his fast ball really wasn't so great). (Really... Google 'Art Pennington')

[BethPeters]

My biggest beef with this one is that Norm said it was an alternative reality in the opening comments. I figured out it was Fidel Castro the first time I heard the guy's name was Fidel. So it wasn't a puzzle at all. I knew where it was going. I am not sure I like puzzles but in this case, the author was not explicitly saying it until the end... so I guess I thought it was meant to be.

The story was not a bad. However, I would have liked the story to read more as a period piece. I think what the story is missing is some additional subtle details of setting. Even the dialogue read as if people were talking today, I think it could have come off a bit more 50s. Maybe, it could have been something as simple as Ritchie Valens playing on the radio or something?
 

He's called Castro in the opening pre-story paragraph and a few times throughout the story as well (just in case a guy named Fidel from Cuba who is having dreams about war, revolution and overturning the government didn't tip you off.)  The author definitely wasn't going for an "It was Fidel Castro the whole time!" twist.

I also can't agree with your other point about setting.  His wife loves watching Lucille Ball on TV, the TV is black and white and he says he's going to get her a color TV when they come out.  There are lots of things that place this in the 50's.

I thought the Desi Arnaz tie in was cool, Desi being a Cuban also.  I agree with Windup that it would have been interesting to see what else would happen in this world as a result of Fidel staying comfortably nestled in capitalism and American life, but at the same time... this is a short story.  It gave us a chapter from a world, concluded nicely while leaving us to wonder about the rest.  I was nervous about it being a "baseball story" because it's not at all an interest of mine, but fortunately this was much more. 
Also, great reading and great outro by Norm.

[AlternateID]

I wasn't a huge fan of the story. My comment is directed at Norm's post story comments. 

Firstly I do love escapepod and plan on making a donation to shows my appreciation of all of your hard work.

That stated, I was disappointed to hear that his post-story comments used a Snopes.com article on Castro word-for-word. Several paragraphs were lifted from the original author and was not cited.

You all do such professional work and are talented artists. Please remember your integrity even when faced with deadlines and financial constraints. 

Again, I love the program and encourage all listeners to make a donation.

[silber]

I enjoyed this one a good bit, although it's not the type of story I usually expect from Escapepod.  Castro was an interesting character and it makes you wonder what any of us might have been in the reversal, if we'd been born in historic situations ripe for revolution or otherwise. 
Also the narration was outstanding for this I thought.  Well done!

[Myst]

My big take away from this story. Who was the Mysterious Cuban who visited Castro and got him thinking about home? Was he just some random Cuban, Was he another alternative history Fidel Castro who lost his revolution and now roams from timeline to timeline searching for one he can "correct"? Or was he just a time traveling troll..

[evrgrn_monster]

I tried really hard to like this, because the writing was great and the narration was engaging. (Bdoomed, you were so cute when you started singing. ) However, alternative history has never been an easy sell for me, and though, with its easy-going pace and ultimate lack of major conflict, this story was not like most A.H. I've seen, it still didn't do it for me. I can lift my disbelief for dragons, spaceships, and Cthulu, but Fidel Castro as a sweet baseball player who just wants to love his girlfriend and watch TV just cancels out any suspension that I could have.

Since we were warned about the one curse word, I was really on the look out for it. However, and I cannot believe I'm writing this sentence, the "ass" in this story was weird. It didn't really match the tone, since the character was using euphemisms for sex and other things. I think a more gentle word would've fit this more gentle man.

[Windup]

I highly suggest reading the notes about the story, published on the escape pod site, after the main story text, for some context that may (or may not) change the lens with which you hear/think about this story.

As for big picture, there was no big picture, not for this Fidel.  He gravitated towards it and was repelled by the political climate of 1950s America.  I think the absence of big picture ends up saying more.  What would a baseball player know about revolution?  What does any one of us know about it?  We are over fed on media and malnourished on fact, imprisoned by our own politics, and Giants player Fidel reflects it.  It's the world where he chooses red hair over his people, continued status quo over something perhaps meaningful and dire.  He places his agency in a television star, because as an enculturated Fidel, he knows nothing else.

I admit I was rather unimpressed and unenthused after first reading the story, but it has grown on me, especially afterconsidering what the author has to say and what the story really has to say.

I read the notes, they were interesting, but they didn't alter my basic opinion of the story.  I get the idea that "A solid contract and a good woman have been the ruin of many a good revolutionary," the anesthetizing power of wealth, imparting political acumen to celebrities, and all that. 

But without a window to the wider world, I don't see how you can tell if that's a Good Thing or a Bad Thing.  Sure, this Fidel is less politically aware.  You can argue that by trading a mediocre baseball career for national leadership, he's failing to reach his potential.  But what happened as a result?  Did someone else lead the Cuban revolution?  Maybe in a more democratic direction?  Was there reform in the existing regime?  Or, without Fidel's leadership, did things get much worse? 

Without the answers to those questions, I can't get all that excited about the problem of whether Fidel achieved self-actualization or not. 

[InfiniteMonkey]

I think I must have read this story when it was printed; it feels very familiar.

The question that I have is: what does Desi know that he's not telling? Clearly he knows more than Fidel, but what is that? Is he more aware of a different reality? More juiced in with more connected and powerful people?

I don't fault the story for not telling me, but I can't help wondering....

[Unblinking]

I found this story very dull.  Not being interested in baseball might not have helped, but really I think the problem is that the events of the story can only possibly be interesting in contrast with real events. 

I mean, obviously that comparison is the entire basis of alternate history, so that being a factor isn't a problem.  But to me at least a story has to be a good and entertaining story apart from any genre considerations expected of it.  If you read alternate history with knowledge of what has changed, you should appreciate it MORE.  But if you aren't aware of what's changed I think that something should still happen. 

A Cuban comes to America to play baseball, and likes it.  He has little interest in politics.  He talks to a famous actor.  The End.

[SF.Fangirl]

I found this story very dull.  ...

A Cuban comes to America to play baseball, and likes it.  He has little interest in politics.  He talks to a famous actor.  The End.

That really nails my thoughts.  The story really had nothing to it; nothing happened.  We're supposed to use our meta POV to realize what Fidel was ignoring/giving up. Instead of asking "what if Castro became a baseball player instead of a leading a revolution?" this story addressed "how might Castro end up a baseball player instead of leading a revolution?" and the how was pretty dull.

[InfiniteMonkey]

That really nails my thoughts.  The story really had nothing to it; nothing happened.  We're supposed to use our meta POV to realize what Fidel was ignoring/giving up. Instead of asking "what if Castro became a baseball player instead of a leading a revolution?" this story addressed "how might Castro end up a baseball player instead of leading a revolution?" and the how was pretty dull.

I think there's a little more going on than that. Clearly Castro is having flashes of his "other" life, which of course begs questions of "destiny" (whatever that means).

Then there's the forces in his world trying to push him one way or another. What do they know? Why chose this ball player? Why try and and knock him off this course?

[Unblinking]

I think there's a little more going on than that. Clearly Castro is having flashes of his "other" life, which of course begs questions of "destiny" (whatever that means).

To me it doesn't so much beg questions of "destiny" but it seems like a clumsy attempt by the author to work in mention of the revolution.

Then there's the forces in his world trying to push him one way or another. What do they know? Why chose this ball player? Why try and and knock him off this course?

Why NOT choose this ball player?  Why not just approach every Cuban baseball player in the American pro leagues because they have enough pull with the public that their opinions could make some difference?  There's no way to tell how many of them have been approached.  I don't see this attention as making Castro special in this world.

[adrianh]

I enjoyed this, but it a very quiet way. For me it was one of those stories that goes exactly how you think it will go - but the journey is enjoyable despite that. I guess my only criticism is that it seemed just a tad too long establishing Earth 2 Castro's lifestyle before his failure to engage in the wider political world.

I also wonder if this is a story that feels different to US readers. Both because of baseball & the way that Castro/Cuba is seen.

On an unrelated note - I got the feeling that Nancy was intended to represent an historical character too. Anybody else get that? If so who?

[Prophet]

I really wanted to like this story. I love alternate history, even highly implausible ones. But this one kinda fell flat for me. Maybe it is because I don't like baseball. Maybe the story could have used more..story. Tell me more about this world, about Castro the ballplayer. Give me more depth to his alternate life. I can always look up what happened to Fidel Castro in real life.

I think there's a little more going on than that. Clearly Castro is having flashes of his "other" life, which of course begs questions of "destiny" (whatever that means).

To me it doesn't so much beg questions of "destiny" but it seems like a clumsy attempt by the author to work in mention of the revolution.

Ditto. It felt clumsy and forced. Maybe if the rest of the story had more meat, it would be easier to take.

On an unrelated note - I got the feeling that Nancy was intended to represent an historical character too. Anybody else get that? If so who?

Funny. I too had that thought. I assume she is fictitious. But then I have missed historical figures in other alternate history stories before.

[chemistryguy]

On an unrelated note - I got the feeling that Nancy was intended to represent an historical character too. Anybody else get that? If so who?

I'll go with Nancy (Davis) Reagan.  Would be just about the right timeline anyhoo.

[CamTurner]

Love alternate history so keep mining that vein, but perhaps this wasn't the jewel we'd hoped for.

Cam

[PotatoKnight]

I guess I'm largely alone in this one but I really liked it. It's pretty bleak but relatable and the alternate history angle gives it a kind of meaning that would be hard to get otherwise.

What do I mean by relatable?  I can certainly sympathize with Castro's position as a comfortable upper-middle-class-type (I'm assuming that, as a non-top level pro ball player of the 50's he's in the upper-middle class range rather than the crazy-wealthy range, but I suppose it doesn't matter a ton) who has a past of idealism. He likes is comforts, loves his girlfriend. It's easy to just ignore suffering, but the suffering is real. Maybe he can do something about the system using his fame?  But Desi makes it clear that this is not an option, and in 1950s America, that seems right to me. What Desi understands is that Castro pretty much has the option of siding with oppressed people of Cuba, being labeled a communist, and giving up all his comforts and his love or of shutting up, throwing the ball, and enjoying the best he can.

In less dramatic form, I'm sure a lot of us face the question of how much of our comfort are we willing to trade for ideals. What volunteer work can we be doing, what other career path that let's us make more positive change. What gives the alternate history of this its punch is that we know the Castro could make a big damn difference--albiet not, in our world, an unambiguously good one. It's not a simple dilemma and for that reason this story has a lot of dramatic punch for me.

[MadeInTheDark]

After listening to this story I was reminded of a quote from John Scalzi's 'Agent to the Stars',"... America's greatest export is not freedom, it is the export of American Culture through it's entertainment industry."

Appreciating  the alternative history genre is often dependent on the reader's grounding in the history on which the story is based. I find the author's speculation on what would have happened if Castro embraced American culture via the professional sports and entertainment industry instead of leading a revolution against American corporate culture interesting and entertaining.

Castro was a baseball player and may have actually had a failed try-out with a pro ball team.

Desi Arnaz embraced American Culture hook. line and sinker.

Bit-o-baseball-irony: Observing that the bulk of Boston Redsox players sported very 'Castro'esque' beards throughout the ALCS series 

[rlzack]

I'm not going to add anything that hasn't been said. I am not normally a fan of alternate history stories - they usually require some obscure knowledge of actual history. In this case, not so much (who doesn't know that Fidel Castro has been the leader of Cuba for the last 50+ years?).

In this case, it is not obvious that Cuba would not become communist just because Castro was not the leader. OK, that sentence has too many negatives - without Castro, is it really clear that Cuba would not have become communist? Was he absolutely essential to that process? The story even notes that there is a revolution. Couldn't the current leader of that revolution have brought the country to communism just as easily? And perhaps with an even worse outcome? Granted, a short story can't necessarily answer all these questions. But in my mind, there was still too much up in the air.

Loved the reading, Bdoomed!!

[knigget]

I read the notes, they were interesting, but they didn't alter my basic opinion of the story.  I get the idea that "A solid contract and a good woman have been the ruin of many a good revolutionary," the anesthetizing power of wealth, imparting political acumen to celebrities, and all that. 

That's plenty; we get way too much romanticizing of revolutions in speculative fiction, and not enough informed contempt.

[Devoted135]

Throughout the story I kept feeling like I was missing veiled references and in-jokes that referred back to the real Castro. Is that true, or was I just imagining that there must be such things? Having never gotten much past WWII in any history class that I took, I know only the very barest of bones about Castro in particular, and the Cuban Revolution in general. Honestly, I think my favorite part of the story was the references to I Love Lucy; my aunt was crazy for that show when I was growing up.

[CryptoMe]

I think I have to agree with the bulk of people here. Fidel the baseball player has a pretty dull life, and without more information on how his dull life affects the reality that I know, that's all it is.

Awesome reading, though, Bdoomed.

[hardware]

I liked it, it was well written, understated look at how someone who we have a very static image of might have turned out to be someone quite different, at least from an outside perspective. You could have done a similar story where Hitler was accepted to Art school I (and probably someone did). The lack of exploration of the big geopolitical changes was actually a strength in my eyes, and I guess that those changes were just about to take place (or not) anyway, and so we can ask ourselves if he still has a role to play, or if he remains pacified by consumer culture.   

[Unblinking]

You could have done a similar story where Hitler was accepted to Art school I (and probably someone did).

Brings to mind "Summer in Paris, Light From the Sky":
http://clarkesworldmagazine.com/scholes_11_07/
I don't recall if Hitler was an art student in that, but along the general idea of what Hitler might've been like if he hadn't become a genocidal maniac dictator.

[Bdoomed]

You could have done a similar story where Hitler was accepted to Art school I (and probably someone did).

Brings to mind "Summer in Paris, Light From the Sky":
http://clarkesworldmagazine.com/scholes_11_07/
I don't recall if Hitler was an art student in that, but along the general idea of what Hitler might've been like if he hadn't become a genocidal maniac dictator.

Also see EP187

[SonofSpermcube]

I was mostly indifferent to this story, but the thing I liked most about it was that IT WAS NOT ABOUT HITLER.  That's one thing the alternate history subgenre needs absolutely no more of. 

[Unblinking]

You could have done a similar story where Hitler was accepted to Art school I (and probably someone did).

Brings to mind "Summer in Paris, Light From the Sky":
http://clarkesworldmagazine.com/scholes_11_07/
I don't recall if Hitler was an art student in that, but along the general idea of what Hitler might've been like if he hadn't become a genocidal maniac dictator.

Also see EP187

Ah, I was thinking it had been on one of the EA casts, but my Google Fu led me to Clarkesworld first.
Here's the EP link for the lazy:
http://escapepod.org/2009/02/07/ep187-summer-in-paris-light-from-the-sky/

[luka datas]

not so much SF as WTF

[eytanz]

Moderator note

not so much SF as WTF

Not so much an acceptable comment as an unacceptable one.

Luka, let me remind you of the forum's one rule. Criticism is welcome. Insults and negative snipes, especially contentless ones, are not.

[luka datas]

since You have given me a warning regarding all my recent comments and I have agreed not to say anything more I wont say anything in my defense because I already have. A defense which you rejected concerning the use of the actual f word within the podcast itself I will say nothing and leave you the last word. As a gentleman must.

[Bdoomed]

since You have given me a warning regarding all my recent comments and I have agreed not to say anything more I wont say anything in my defense because I already have. A defense which you rejected concerning the use of the actual f word within the podcast itself I will say nothing and leave you the last word. As a gentleman must.

I have no idea what you just said here.  None.

[Scattercat]

He's trying to take his private beefs public in the hopes of garnering sympathy.

You know. 

Like a gentleman.

[eytanz]

I will say nothing and leave you the last word.

Potato

(I figured that since I got the last word, I should make it one I enjoy)

[luka datas]

being a gentleman is hard.

[Unblinking]

I will say nothing and leave you the last word.

Potato

(I figured that since I got the last word, I should make it one I enjoy)

Rutabaga! 

It's much more fun to say than potato.

Also, susurrus!

[Fenrix]

I will say nothing and leave you the last word.

Potato

(I figured that since I got the last word, I should make it one I enjoy)

Rutabaga! 

It's much more fun to say than potato.

Also, susurrus!

I like a good atlatl preferably in an atlatl battle.

[EosTwelve]

I just finished this one last night. The story was kind of bland. Out of all the possible life lines, why this one? Why a baseball player? Why not a hockey player, tennis player, an actor, a chef? I think I would have been more interested in another life line hopefully. Alternate life lines in SF I get - this story should have been sent back and reserected along a different life. I liked the way the author put everything together, and the reading was good, I just feel it has the potential to be so much better! This is one of those stories I would love to see in a rewrite.

[Tarragon]

I assuming the author went with this timeline because Fidel Castro actually played baseball and there is a long standing, but false, story that he tried out with an american team.  
http://www.baseball-reference.com/bullpen/Fidel_Castro

[Unblinking]

I assuming the author went with this timeline because Fidel Castro actually played baseball and there is a long standing, but false, story that he tried out with an american team.  
http://www.baseball-reference.com/bullpen/Fidel_Castro

Yeah, I think that's the reason why baseball.  I agree it wasn't very interesting, but the reason of "why baseball?" seems pretty clear.

[EosTwelve]

So, I have been thinking on this one, and I believe the reason why it didn't sit right with me was because I have become so use to the authors of these types of stories to go for the more exciting, exotic scripts. When I look at it like that, then I have come to realise that this wasn't such a bad story after all. Hence I recind my "bland" comment with all apologies. I still don't like the baseball thing though. Should have made Castro an enforcer on a death hockey team...sorry, just a suggestion  *sigh - scurries back to the dark corner*

[Unblinking]

sorry, just a suggestion  *sigh - scurries back to the dark corner*

No need to apologize, nor to scurry back to the dark corner.  Or at least, if you're going to hang out in that dark corner, you don't have to feel like you can't participate in the conversation anyway. 

[EosTwelve]

No worries! I tend to hide in dark corners, then dart out to post every once in a while. Besides, I'm still trying to get caught up on my listening 

[Unblinking]

No worries! I tend to hide in dark corners, then dart out to post every once in a while. Besides, I'm still trying to get caught up on my listening 

Feel free to comment on old stuff, even the oldest stuff--threadomancy is welcome here.