Hmm, good one, Fenrix! I also like that it's a Fowlie narration. Fowlie is pretty much mandatory for this project.
Has Graeme read anything in G/PG territory? I'd love to include his voice somewhere in this set. Also, MK Hobson?
Here's what else I'm thinking about including so far, glancing through my library (this list is dude-narrator-heavy, but that's actually on purpose):
From PodCastle:
PC Miniature 13 - Fable of the Ostrich (read by Steve Eley)
PC 106 - Little Gods (read by Dave Thompson)
PC 165 - The Paper Menagerie (read by Rajan Khanna)
PC 243 - Tiger in the BSE (read by TCA Lakshmi Narasimhan)
PC 259 - The Great Zeppelin Heist of Oz (read by Nick Podel)
PC 280 - The Devil and Tom Walker (read by Wilson Fowlie)
PC 285 - Dragonslayer (read by Elie Hirschman)
PC 287 - Tiktok and the Nome King (read by Bob Eccles)
PC 322 - Saving Bacon (read by Alasdair Stuart)
From Escape Pod:
EP 407 - Mono No Aware (read by John Chu)
EP 427 - Samantha's Diary (read by Emma Newman)
EP 430 - Heart of Joy (read by Andrea Richardson)
EP 453 - Grotto of the Dancing Deer (read by Norm Sherman)
EP 455 - Keep Your Shape (read by Nathan Lee)
I can't think of anything particularly tame from PP yet, but I've not delved that far into the back catalogue. Definitely open to recommendations though.